Skip to content

IELTS Reading · Reading Passage 3

How writing began: matching theories

Matching Features practice, questions 31–35, with the full passage and every answer explained. Try the questions first; the answers are folded away below.

Questions
31–35
Passage
681 words
Level
Harder
Part
2 of 3 on this passage

How Writing Began

AWriting is so central to modern life that it is easy to assume it was always destined to appear. Yet for most of human history people managed without it, and when it did arrive, it seems to have done so in only a handful of places. The earliest known examples come from southern Mesopotamia, in what is now Iraq, where clay tablets from the city of Uruk dating to around 3200 BCE record quantities of grain, livestock and labour. Egyptian hieroglyphs appear at roughly the same time, Chinese characters on the so-called oracle bones of the Shang dynasty from about 1200 BCE, and writing in Mesoamerica several centuries later. Why writing emerged, and whether it was invented once or many times, remain matters of lively debate.

BThe most influential account of the Mesopotamian case is the token theory, developed by the archaeologist Denise Schmandt-Besserat. Across the Near East, from as early as 8000 BCE, people used small clay tokens of various shapes, cones, spheres and discs, to stand for goods such as measures of grain or jars of oil. Later, tokens were sealed inside hollow clay balls, known as envelopes, to record a transaction, and their shapes were pressed into the outside so that the contents could be checked without breaking the envelope open. Eventually, the argument runs, people realised that the impressions alone were enough, and the tokens themselves became unnecessary. Flat tablets bearing marks replaced the envelopes, and writing was born.

CI find the token theory attractive, not least because it explains why the earliest Mesopotamian texts are so dull. They are not poems or prayers but accounts: lists of goods, payments and debts. Writing, on this view, was invented by bookkeepers, and literature came much later. Critics have pointed out, however, that the link between particular token shapes and particular written signs is weaker than the theory requires; only some of the early signs resemble tokens. The theory may describe one route to writing without describing the only one.

DA rival view, sometimes called the diffusion theory, holds that writing was invented only once, in Mesopotamia, and that other peoples borrowed the idea, if not the signs, from their neighbours. The appearance of Egyptian hieroglyphs so soon after the Mesopotamian tablets, and the known trade links between the two regions, are taken as evidence that the Egyptians learnt of writing from others. In my view, this argument is weakest where it matters most. Egyptian writing looks nothing like Mesopotamian writing, and some of the earliest Egyptian inscriptions may be as old as any from Uruk.

EMost scholars now accept that writing was invented independently at least three times: in Mesopotamia, in China and in Mesoamerica, and possibly a fourth time in Egypt. No plausible route exists by which the idea could have crossed from the Near East to the Americas, so the Mesoamerican scripts at least must be original creations. This independent invention view has a striking implication. If people in very different societies arrived at writing separately, then it is presumably something that tends to happen once a society reaches a certain size and complexity.

FNot every early script, however, seems to have begun with accounts. The oldest Chinese writing appears on bones and turtle shells used in divination: questions were inscribed and put to the ancestors, and the bones were heated until they cracked, the cracks being read as answers. Supporters of a ritual theory argue that writing first served religion and kingship rather than trade. They may be right about China, although it is possible that earlier writing on perishable materials such as bamboo has simply not survived.

GWhat these competing theories share is a reminder that writing was not a single discovery but a slow series of steps, each solving a practical problem. I am sceptical of any account that claims to explain every script by the same cause. The bookkeepers of Uruk and the diviners of the Shang court had different needs, and it would be surprising if they had answered them in the same way.

Questions 31–35

Match each statement with the correct theory, A, B, C or D. You may use any letter more than once.

  • Athe token theory
  • Bthe diffusion theory
  • Cthe independent invention view
  • Dthe ritual theory
  1. 31suggests that writing tends to appear when societies become large and complex
  2. 32relies on the closeness in time between two early writing systems
  3. 33claims that written marks replaced the objects they originally represented
  4. 34connects the beginnings of writing with communication with the dead
  5. 35has been criticised because only some early signs look like the objects it describes

Answers and explanations

Open one at a time to check as you go, or the key to mark them all.

Answer key: Questions 31–35Show
  1. 31C the independent invention view
  2. 32B the diffusion theory
  3. 33A the token theory
  4. 34D the ritual theory
  5. 35A the token theory
31suggests that writing tends to appear when societies become large and complexAnswer

Answer: C the independent invention view

Paragraph E: if writing arose separately in different societies, “it is presumably something that tends to happen once a society reaches a certain size and complexity”.

32relies on the closeness in time between two early writing systemsAnswer

Answer: B the diffusion theory

Paragraph D: “The appearance of Egyptian hieroglyphs so soon after the Mesopotamian tablets … are taken as evidence” for borrowing.

33claims that written marks replaced the objects they originally representedAnswer

Answer: A the token theory

Paragraph B: impressions on envelopes were enough, “and the tokens themselves became unnecessary”.

34connects the beginnings of writing with communication with the deadAnswer

Answer: D the ritual theory

Paragraph F: questions were inscribed and “put to the ancestors”; the ritual theory says writing first served religion.

35has been criticised because only some early signs look like the objects it describesAnswer

Answer: A the token theory

Paragraph C: critics say the link is weak because “only some of the early signs resemble tokens”.

The rest of this passage

Other question types on the same text, like the paper.

More Matching Features practice

Common questions

Are these real IELTS Reading questions?

No. They're original practice questions written in the official IELTS format and numbering, with answers and explanations. Real test questions aren't published.

How should I use the answers?

Answer every question first, then check. For each one you got wrong, read the explanation and find the line in the passage that gives the answer: that's where the trap or paraphrase is.

Answer it in the app

See right and wrong at once with the reason for each. Free to start, nothing to install.