Skip to content

IELTS Reading · Reading Passage 1

Pen or keyboard: matching people

Matching Features practice, questions 6–10, with the full passage and every answer explained. Try the questions first; the answers are folded away below.

Questions
6–10
Passage
651 words
Level
Easier
Part
2 of 3 on this passage

Pen or Keyboard?

AWalk into any university lecture theatre and you will see rows of open laptops, their owners typing almost every word the lecturer says. A decade ago, a widely reported experiment suggested that this was a mistake. Students who took notes by hand, it found, understood the material better than those who typed, even though the typists recorded far more of what was said. The finding was taken up enthusiastically by teachers and journalists, and some lecturers banned laptops from their classes altogether. I think the evidence deserves a more careful reading than it has usually received.

BThe explanation offered for the original result was persuasive. Because most people type much faster than they write, typists tend to copy lectures word for word, without pausing to think. Writers, unable to keep up, are forced to summarise, and summarising requires them to process what they hear. On this view, the pen does not help directly; it helps by slowing the student down. The neuroscientist Professor Ahmed Saleh adds a further explanation. Using recordings of brain activity, he found that forming letters by hand engages areas of the brain involved in memory more strongly than pressing keys does.

CThe trouble is that the original experiment has proved hard to repeat. The education researcher Dr Ruth Calloway ran a larger version with more than 400 students and found that the gap between handwriting and typing was much smaller than first reported, and disappeared entirely on some kinds of question. Calloway does not claim that typing is better, only that the advantage of handwriting is modest and depends on what is being tested. Since then, other studies have produced similarly mixed results. It seems to me that the honest conclusion is that we do not yet know how large the difference is.

DWhat does seem clear is that distraction is a serious problem. A laptop connected to the internet offers messages, news and shopping, and students who use them in class spend a surprising amount of time on things unrelated to the lecture. The economist Dr Lars Eriksen compared examination results at a university before and after one department began allowing laptops in seminars, and found that marks fell slightly, most of all among weaker students. Eriksen also found that students sitting behind someone using a laptop did worse, which suggests that the distraction spreads.

ESuch findings have convinced some teachers to act. Megan Doyle, who teaches history at a secondary school in Leeds, asked her pupils to put their laptops away for one term and found that discussion in her lessons became livelier. She admits, however, that several pupils with dyslexia or poor handwriting found the change difficult, and she now allows them to type. This, in my view, is the strongest argument against a blanket ban. For some students a keyboard is not a convenience but a necessity, and forcing them to write by hand would put them at a clear disadvantage.

FThere is also a risk that the debate focuses on the wrong question. Whether students write or type, notes are only as useful as what is done with them afterwards. Saleh points out that students who review and reorganise their notes within a day of a lecture remember far more than those who do not, whatever tool they used. Teaching students how to take notes, and how to use them, would probably achieve more than any rule about laptops.

GI would not, therefore, ban laptops from lecture theatres. I would, however, encourage students to switch off their internet connection during class, and to try taking notes by hand for a few weeks to see whether it suits them. The research has not shown that the pen is mightier than the keyboard. It has shown that how we take notes matters, and that the habits we bring to the task may matter more than the device.

Questions 6–10

Match each statement with the correct person, A, B, C or D. You may use any letter more than once.

  • AAhmed Saleh
  • BRuth Calloway
  • CLars Eriksen
  • DMegan Doyle
  1. 6found that the effect of laptops reached students who were not using them
  2. 7changed a rule after seeing its effect on certain learners
  3. 8studied how the brain responds to different ways of writing
  4. 9repeated an earlier study with a bigger group of participants
  5. 10emphasises the value of going back over notes soon after a class

Answers and explanations

Open one at a time to check as you go, or the key to mark them all.

Answer key: Questions 6–10Show
  1. 6C Lars Eriksen
  2. 7D Megan Doyle
  3. 8A Ahmed Saleh
  4. 9B Ruth Calloway
  5. 10A Ahmed Saleh
6found that the effect of laptops reached students who were not using themAnswer

Answer: C Lars Eriksen

Paragraph D: Eriksen “found that students sitting behind someone using a laptop did worse”.

7changed a rule after seeing its effect on certain learnersAnswer

Answer: D Megan Doyle

Paragraph E: Doyle found pupils with dyslexia or poor handwriting struggled, “and she now allows them to type”.

8studied how the brain responds to different ways of writingAnswer

Answer: A Ahmed Saleh

Paragraph B: Saleh used recordings of brain activity and found handwriting “engages areas of the brain involved in memory more strongly”.

9repeated an earlier study with a bigger group of participantsAnswer

Answer: B Ruth Calloway

Paragraph C: Calloway “ran a larger version with more than 400 students”.

10emphasises the value of going back over notes soon after a classAnswer

Answer: A Ahmed Saleh

Paragraph F: “Saleh points out that students who review and reorganise their notes within a day of a lecture remember far more.”

The rest of this passage

Other question types on the same text, like the paper.

More Matching Features practice

Common questions

Are these real IELTS Reading questions?

No. They're original practice questions written in the official IELTS format and numbering, with answers and explanations. Real test questions aren't published.

How should I use the answers?

Answer every question first, then check. For each one you got wrong, read the explanation and find the line in the passage that gives the answer: that's where the trap or paraphrase is.

Answer it in the app

See right and wrong at once with the reason for each. Free to start, nothing to install.