Skip to content

IELTS Reading · Reading Passage 3

The limits of the nudge: matching people

Matching Features practice, questions 32–35, with the full passage and every answer explained. Try the questions first; the answers are folded away below.

Questions
32–35
Passage
681 words
Level
Harder
Part
2 of 3 on this passage

The Limits of the Nudge

AIn 2008 the economist Richard Thaler and the legal scholar Cass Sunstein published a book with a deceptively modest title, Nudge. Its argument was that people’s choices are strongly influenced by the way options are presented, and that governments could use this fact to steer citizens towards better decisions without forbidding anything or changing financial incentives. Put the fruit at eye level in a school canteen and the chips at the back, and children will eat more fruit; nobody is prevented from choosing chips. Within a few years, governments around the world had set up units dedicated to applying these ideas, beginning with Britain’s Behavioural Insights Team in 2010.

BSome early results were striking. Dr Nadia Osman, who worked on a series of trials for a national tax authority, found that adding a single sentence to reminder letters, stating that most people in the recipient’s town had already paid, increased the number of people who paid on time by several percentage points. Because millions of letters were sent each year, the change brought in substantial sums at almost no cost. Defaults proved even more powerful. In countries where citizens are automatically registered as organ donors unless they opt out, registration rates are far higher than in countries where people must opt in, even though the choice is equally free in both. Similar effects have been found when employees are automatically enrolled in pension schemes.

CI was, I admit, an early enthusiast. Nudges seemed to offer that rarest of things in public policy: a cheap measure that worked and that offended nobody. Over time, however, my enthusiasm has cooled, for two quite different reasons.

DThe first concerns the evidence. In 2021 the behavioural economist Dr Clara Voss combined the results of more than 200 published nudge experiments and reported that, on average, they had a moderate effect on behaviour. Her analysis was widely cited as proof that nudging works. However, the statistician Dr Tom Brennan pointed out that studies finding no effect are less likely to be published, and when he adjusted Voss’s figures to allow for this, the average effect shrank almost to nothing. Voss accepts that publication bias exists but argues that Brennan’s adjustment is too severe, and that some kinds of nudge, particularly defaults, remain effective after any reasonable correction. My own reading is that she is right about defaults, and that the evidence for many other nudges is far weaker than was once claimed.

EThe second reason is philosophical. Professor James Whitfield, a moral philosopher, argues that nudges work precisely because they bypass our reasoning. A sign that appeals to our desire to fit in, or a default that relies on our inertia, does not persuade us; it manages us. Whitfield does not think all nudges are wrong, but he believes they should be used openly, so that citizens can see and challenge them. I share his concern, although I think he overstates it. A government that sends a reminder letter is hardly manipulating anyone, and the alternative, presenting choices in no particular order, is not neutral either: someone still has to decide which option comes first.

FThere is also a practical worry. Nudges are attractive to politicians partly because they are cheap, and that very cheapness can become an excuse for inaction. Encouraging people to eat more healthily by rearranging canteens is easier than regulating the food industry; prompting people to save for retirement is easier than raising wages. When a nudge is offered in place of a more demanding policy, it may achieve less than nothing, because it allows a government to claim that it has acted while the underlying problem remains untouched.

GNone of this means that the nudge units should be closed. They brought to government a welcome habit of testing policies on a small scale before adopting them, and some of their findings, especially about defaults, have proved durable. But nudges are a tool, not a philosophy of government. Used alongside regulation and investment, they can help; used instead of them, they are likely to disappoint.

Questions 32–35

Match each statement with the correct person or people, A, B, C, D or E. You may use any letter more than once.

  • ARichard Thaler and Cass Sunstein
  • BNadia Osman
  • CClara Voss
  • DTom Brennan
  • EJames Whitfield
  1. 32maintains that one type of nudge still works once the data have been corrected
  2. 33thinks the public should be able to see when nudges are being used
  3. 34found that telling people about the behaviour of their neighbours had an effect
  4. 35showed that an apparent effect almost vanished once unpublished research was taken into account

Answers and explanations

Open one at a time to check as you go, or the key to mark them all.

Answer key: Questions 32–35Show
  1. 32C Clara Voss
  2. 33E James Whitfield
  3. 34B Nadia Osman
  4. 35D Tom Brennan
32maintains that one type of nudge still works once the data have been correctedAnswer

Answer: C Clara Voss

Paragraph D: Voss argues “that some kinds of nudge, particularly defaults, remain effective after any reasonable correction”.

33thinks the public should be able to see when nudges are being usedAnswer

Answer: E James Whitfield

Paragraph E: Whitfield believes nudges “should be used openly, so that citizens can see and challenge them”.

34found that telling people about the behaviour of their neighbours had an effectAnswer

Answer: B Nadia Osman

Paragraph B: Osman’s letters stated “that most people in the recipient’s town had already paid”, and more people paid on time.

35showed that an apparent effect almost vanished once unpublished research was taken into accountAnswer

Answer: D Tom Brennan

Paragraph D: when Brennan allowed for studies that are not published, “the average effect shrank almost to nothing”.

The rest of this passage

Other question types on the same text, like the paper.

More Matching Features practice

Common questions

Are these real IELTS Reading questions?

No. They're original practice questions written in the official IELTS format and numbering, with answers and explanations. Real test questions aren't published.

How should I use the answers?

Answer every question first, then check. For each one you got wrong, read the explanation and find the line in the passage that gives the answer: that's where the trap or paraphrase is.

Answer it in the app

See right and wrong at once with the reason for each. Free to start, nothing to install.