Skip to content

IELTS Reading · Reading Passage 2

The placebo effect: which paragraph?

Matching Information practice, questions 14–19, with the full passage and every answer explained. Try the questions first; the answers are folded away below.

Questions
14–19
Passage
659 words
Level
Medium
Part
1 of 2 on this passage

The Power of Expectation

AIn 1955 the American anaesthetist Henry Beecher published a paper with a striking title, 'The Powerful Placebo'. Reviewing more than a dozen studies, he concluded that roughly a third of patients experienced relief from their symptoms after receiving treatments, such as sugar pills or salt-water injections, that contained no active ingredient. Beecher is said to have become interested in the subject while serving as a military doctor in the Second World War, when he noticed that some badly wounded soldiers seemed to feel surprisingly little pain. Later analysts found serious flaws in his calculations, but the paper helped to establish the placebo-controlled trial, in which a new drug is compared with an inactive substitute, as the standard method for testing medicines.

BMuch of the improvement seen in patients given placebos, critics pointed out, has nothing to do with the placebo itself. Many illnesses get better on their own, and symptoms such as pain naturally rise and fall, so patients who seek treatment when they feel at their worst are likely to feel better later whatever they receive. To measure a true placebo effect, researchers must compare patients given a placebo with others given nothing at all. When this is done, the effect on objective measures such as blood tests often shrinks or disappears; its influence on subjective experiences such as pain, nausea and fatigue, however, is frequently real and substantial.

CBrain-imaging studies have begun to explain how this happens. When people expect pain relief, regions of the brain involved in processing pain become less active, and the body releases its own painkilling chemicals, known as endorphins. In one experiment, the placebo effect on pain largely disappeared when participants were given a drug that blocks the action of endorphins. This is strong evidence that the effect has a physical basis, rather than being simply a matter of patients reporting what they think researchers want to hear.

DThe details of a treatment influence how well a placebo works. Two pills tend to produce a larger effect than one, injections a larger effect than pills, and branded tablets a larger one than plain ones. Colour may matter too: in some surveys, people associate red and orange pills with stimulating effects and blue ones with calming effects. In one study, volunteers given a pill they were told cost $2.50 reported more relief from mild electric shocks than those told that the identical pill had been discounted to ten cents. Real medicines also benefit from expectation: patients who watch a doctor inject a painkiller tend to experience more relief than those who receive the same dose secretly through an automatic pump.

EExpectation can harm as well as heal. The so-called nocebo effect occurs when negative expectations produce unpleasant symptoms. In trials of new drugs, a considerable proportion of patients given a placebo report side effects such as headaches or dizziness, often matching those listed in the information they were given before the trial. In some studies, patients who had been warned about a particular side effect were considerably more likely to report it than those who had not. Some researchers believe that many complaints attributed to medicines are partly caused by this mechanism, and that the way doctors describe possible side effects can affect how often they occur.

FPerhaps the most surprising recent finding is that placebos may work even when patients know what they are taking. In a study of people with irritable bowel syndrome, participants were openly given pills described as containing no medicine, and told that such pills had produced improvements in other studies. After three weeks they reported greater relief than a group who received no treatment. Such open-label placebos avoid the ethical problem of deceiving patients, and trials are now testing them for conditions including chronic back pain. Doctors remain cautious, however: no placebo can shrink a tumour or cure an infection, and relying on one where effective treatment exists could be dangerous.

Questions 14–19

The reading passage has six paragraphs, A–F. Which paragraph contains the following information?

  • AParagraph A
  • BParagraph B
  • CParagraph C
  • DParagraph D
  • EParagraph E
  • FParagraph F
  1. 14an experiment involving the price of a treatment
  2. 15a way of separating genuine placebo effects from natural recovery
  3. 16evidence that placebo effects have a biological cause
  4. 17a concern about depending on placebos
  5. 18an influential publication that contained mistakes
  6. 19a suggestion that the way information is given can cause symptoms

Answers and explanations

Open one at a time to check as you go, or the key to mark them all.

Answer key: Questions 14–19Show
  1. 14D Paragraph D
  2. 15B Paragraph B
  3. 16C Paragraph C
  4. 17F Paragraph F
  5. 18A Paragraph A
  6. 19E Paragraph E
14an experiment involving the price of a treatmentAnswer

Answer: D Paragraph D

Paragraph D: a pill 'they were told cost $2.50' worked better than one 'discounted to ten cents'.

15a way of separating genuine placebo effects from natural recoveryAnswer

Answer: B Paragraph B

Paragraph B: 'researchers must compare patients given a placebo with others given nothing at all'.

16evidence that placebo effects have a biological causeAnswer

Answer: C Paragraph C

Paragraph C: blocking endorphins removed the effect, 'strong evidence that the effect has a physical basis'.

17a concern about depending on placebosAnswer

Answer: F Paragraph F

Paragraph F: 'relying on one where effective treatment exists could be dangerous'.

18an influential publication that contained mistakesAnswer

Answer: A Paragraph A

Paragraph A: 'Later analysts found serious flaws in his calculations, but the paper helped to establish the placebo-controlled trial'.

19a suggestion that the way information is given can cause symptomsAnswer

Answer: E Paragraph E

Paragraph E: 'the way doctors describe possible side effects can affect how often they occur'.

The rest of this passage

Other question types on the same text, like the paper.

More Matching Information practice

Common questions

Are these real IELTS Reading questions?

No. They're original practice questions written in the official IELTS format and numbering, with answers and explanations. Real test questions aren't published.

How should I use the answers?

Answer every question first, then check. For each one you got wrong, read the explanation and find the line in the passage that gives the answer: that's where the trap or paraphrase is.

Answer it in the app

See right and wrong at once with the reason for each. Free to start, nothing to install.