Skip to content

IELTS Reading · Reading Passage 1

The Power of the Placebo: multiple choice

Multiple Choice practice, questions 5–9, with the full passage and every answer explained. Try the questions first; the answers are folded away below.

Questions
5–9
Passage
676 words
Level
Easier
Part
2 of 3 on this passage

The Power of the Placebo

AFor centuries, doctors have known that patients sometimes feel better after receiving a treatment that contains no active ingredient. A sugar pill, an injection of salt water or even a sham operation can relieve symptoms, provided the patient believes that it might work. This is the placebo effect, and it is the reason why new medicines are tested against dummy treatments: a drug is only judged effective if it does better than a placebo, not simply better than nothing. The word itself comes from Latin and means 'I shall please', a reminder that such remedies were once given mainly to comfort patients rather than to cure them.

BPlacebos are not equally effective for every condition. Their effects are strongest for symptoms that patients experience and report themselves, such as pain, nausea, tiredness and anxiety. They are much weaker, or absent, for conditions that can be measured objectively. A placebo may make a patient with asthma feel less breathless, for example, without making any difference to how well the lungs actually work. For this reason, researchers warn against claims that belief alone can cure serious diseases.

CThat does not mean the effect is imaginary. In a classic experiment, patients who had had teeth removed were given a placebo that they were told was a painkiller, and many reported less pain. When some of them were then given a drug that blocks the action of the body's natural painkilling chemicals, the relief disappeared. This showed that the placebo had triggered a genuine physical response in the brain. Brain scans have since shown that placebos can change activity in regions involved in processing pain.

DCuriously, the details of a placebo matter. In various studies, two pills have worked better than one, capsules better than tablets, and injections better than pills. Price makes a difference too: in one experiment, volunteers who were told that a dummy painkiller was expensive reported more relief than those who were told it had been reduced in price. Even the colour of a pill can influence how it is perceived, with some patients finding blue pills more calming and red ones more stimulating. What these findings have in common is expectation. The more impressive or powerful a treatment seems, the more the patient expects from it.

EThe same mechanism can work in reverse. When patients are warned about possible side effects, some of them experience those side effects even when they are taking a placebo. In clinical trials, some patients who have been given dummy pills even withdraw from the study because of the side effects they report. This is known as the nocebo effect, and it creates a dilemma for doctors, who are required to inform patients about risks but may, by doing so, make unpleasant symptoms more likely. Some researchers suggest that the way the information is presented, for example by emphasising how many people do not experience a side effect, could reduce the problem.

FPerhaps the most surprising recent finding is that placebos may work even when patients know they are taking one. In several trials, people with long-term conditions such as back pain were given pills openly described as containing no medicine, and told only that placebos had helped others. Many reported improvements compared with patients who received no pills at all. The physician Dr Lukas Brenner, who has run such trials, believes the ritual of taking a pill, and the attention of a caring professional, may matter as much as belief. 'We have tended to think of the placebo as a trick,' he says, 'but it may be closer to a part of good care.'

GNot everyone is convinced. Critics point out that patients who know they are receiving a placebo may report improvements in order to please the researchers, and that open-label trials have so far been small. Brenner accepts that larger studies are needed. However, he argues that if the effect is confirmed, it could allow doctors to offer something to patients for whom no effective drug exists, without deceiving them.

Questions 5–9

Choose the correct letter, A, B, C or D.

  1. 5According to paragraph B, placebos work best for A conditions that doctors can measure accurately. B serious diseases. C symptoms that patients notice and describe themselves. D problems with breathing.
  2. 6What did the experiment with dental patients show? A The placebo caused a real physical response. B The patients had imagined their pain. C The painkiller worked better than the placebo. D The patients' pain had disappeared completely.
  3. 7What do the findings in paragraph D have in common? A They all concern the price of treatment. B They all involve the patient's expectations. C They all compare pills with injections. D They all show that colour affects mood.
  4. 8What dilemma does the nocebo effect create for doctors? A They cannot tell which patients are taking a placebo. B Their patients may refuse to take medicine. C Warning patients about side effects may make those side effects more likely. D They must stop prescribing drugs with side effects.
  5. 9Why does Dr Brenner think open-label placebos may work? A The patients secretly believe the pills contain medicine. B The pills are cheaper than real drugs. C Back pain is easy to treat. D The routine of taking a pill and the care involved may help.

Answers and explanations

Open one at a time to check as you go, or the key to mark them all.

Answer key: Questions 5–9Show
  1. 5C symptoms that patients notice and describe themselves.
  2. 6A The placebo caused a real physical response.
  3. 7B They all involve the patient's expectations.
  4. 8C Warning patients about side effects may make those side effects more likely.
  5. 9D The routine of taking a pill and the care involved may help.
5According to paragraph B, placebos work best forAnswer

Answer: C symptoms that patients notice and describe themselves.

Paragraph B: 'Their effects are strongest for symptoms that patients experience and report themselves'. A and B are where effects are 'much weaker, or absent'.

6What did the experiment with dental patients show?Answer

Answer: A The placebo caused a real physical response.

Paragraph C: 'the placebo had triggered a genuine physical response in the brain'. The paragraph begins by saying the effect is not 'imaginary', which rules out B.

7What do the findings in paragraph D have in common?Answer

Answer: B They all involve the patient's expectations.

Paragraph D: 'What these findings have in common is expectation'. Price, form and colour are only individual examples.

8What dilemma does the nocebo effect create for doctors?Answer

Answer: C Warning patients about side effects may make those side effects more likely.

Paragraph E: doctors 'are required to inform patients about risks but may, by doing so, make unpleasant symptoms more likely'.

9Why does Dr Brenner think open-label placebos may work?Answer

Answer: D The routine of taking a pill and the care involved may help.

Paragraph F: 'the ritual of taking a pill, and the attention of a caring professional, may matter as much as belief'. Option A goes against the point that patients 'know they are taking one'.

The rest of this passage

Other question types on the same text, like the paper.

More Multiple Choice practice

Common questions

Are these real IELTS Reading questions?

No. They're original practice questions written in the official IELTS format and numbering, with answers and explanations. Real test questions aren't published.

How should I use the answers?

Answer every question first, then check. For each one you got wrong, read the explanation and find the line in the passage that gives the answer: that's where the trap or paraphrase is.

Answer it in the app

See right and wrong at once with the reason for each. Free to start, nothing to install.