IELTS Reading · Reading Passage 1
The Secrets of Roman Concrete: multiple choice
Multiple Choice practice, questions 6–10, with the full passage and every answer explained. Try the questions first; the answers are folded away below.
- Questions
- 6–10
- Passage
- 669 words
- Level
- Medium
- Part
- 2 of 3 on this passage
The Secrets of Roman Concrete
ANearly two thousand years after it was built, the dome of the Pantheon in Rome remains the largest dome of unreinforced concrete in the world. Roman harbour walls that have stood in the Mediterranean since the first century BC are, in some places, stronger now than when they were made. Modern concrete, by contrast, often begins to crack and crumble within a century, particularly when exposed to salt water. It is not surprising, then, that engineers have spent decades trying to work out what the Romans knew that we do not.
BPart of the answer lies in the ingredients. Roman builders mixed lime with a volcanic ash found around the Bay of Naples, especially near the town of Pozzuoli, from which the material takes its modern name, pozzolana. The Roman architect Vitruvius, writing in the first century BC, praised this ash for its ability to make structures that would set hard even under water. Builders also added chunks of rock or broken brick, known as aggregate, which were laid in layers rather than poured as a liquid, as modern concrete is.
CFor many years it was assumed that the lime and ash simply reacted to form a strong binding material, much as modern cement does. Research on samples drilled from ancient harbours, however, has revealed something more unusual. When seawater seeps through the concrete, it slowly dissolves parts of the volcanic ash and allows new minerals to grow in the pores and cracks. Among them are rare, plate-shaped crystals that reinforce the material from within. In effect, the very process that destroys modern marine concrete makes the Roman version stronger over time.
DA second discovery concerns the small white lumps of lime that are scattered throughout many samples of Roman concrete. These had long been dismissed as evidence of careless mixing or poor-quality materials. A team led by the materials scientist Dr Paolo Ferrante has proposed instead that they were the result of a deliberate technique, in which quicklime was added directly to the mix rather than first being combined with water. This produces intense heat, and the lumps that remain act as a reserve of lime. When a crack forms and water enters it, the lime dissolves and then hardens again, sealing the crack. In laboratory tests, cracked samples made in this way repaired themselves within a few weeks, while samples made without the lumps did not.
EIt would be wrong, though, to conclude that Roman concrete is simply better than its modern equivalent. It is far weaker in compression, meaning that it cannot carry the enormous loads that modern buildings and bridges require, and it sets much more slowly. Nor does it work well with steel reinforcing bars, which allow modern concrete to be used in thin beams and tall towers. The Romans compensated by building massive walls and by shaping their structures, such as arches and domes, so that the forces acting on them were mainly compressive.
FNevertheless, the Roman example has practical relevance. The manufacture of modern cement involves heating limestone to around 1,450°C, a process that releases large quantities of carbon dioxide, both from the fuel and from the limestone itself. Cement production is estimated to account for around seven to eight per cent of global emissions. Roman lime was produced at lower temperatures, and volcanic ash requires no heating at all. Some engineers believe that adding volcanic ash or similar materials to modern mixes could reduce emissions while improving durability, especially for structures such as sea walls, where great strength matters less than a long life.
GSeveral companies are now testing such mixes, and the self-healing approach in particular has attracted interest. Ferrante is cautious about the timescale. Building codes, he points out, are rightly conservative, and any new material must prove itself over many years before it is approved for widespread use. Still, he suggests, there is something fitting about the idea that the future of construction might be found in the ruins of Rome.
Questions 6–10
Choose the correct letter, A, B, C or D.
- 6According to paragraph C, seawater affects Roman concrete by A washing the lime out of it. B allowing new minerals to form inside it. C making it expand and crack. D slowly weakening the aggregate.
- 7What did Dr Ferrante's team propose about the lumps of lime? A They were added after the concrete had set. B They came from poor-quality volcanic ash. C They were produced by a deliberate method of mixing. D They made the concrete set more quickly.
- 8In paragraph E, the writer points out that Roman concrete A cannot support loads as heavy as modern concrete can. B is stronger in compression than modern concrete. C can be combined successfully with steel bars. D sets faster than modern concrete.
- 9Why did the Romans build arches and domes of particular shapes? A to use less concrete in each building B to allow steel to be added later C to make their buildings look more impressive D so that the main forces acting on them were compressive
- 10Why does Ferrante think new mixes will take time to be widely used? A They are much more expensive than modern concrete. B Building rules require new materials to be tested for many years. C Companies have shown little interest in them. D Suitable volcanic ash is hard to find.
Answers and explanations
Open one at a time to check as you go, or the key to mark them all.
Answer key: Questions 6–10Show
- 6B allowing new minerals to form inside it.
- 7C They were produced by a deliberate method of mixing.
- 8A cannot support loads as heavy as modern concrete can.
- 9D so that the main forces acting on them were compressive
- 10B Building rules require new materials to be tested for many years.
6According to paragraph C, seawater affects Roman concrete byAnswer
Answer: B allowing new minerals to form inside it.
Paragraph C: seawater 'allows new minerals to grow in the pores and cracks'. Cracking and weakening describe what seawater does to modern marine concrete, not the Roman version.
7What did Dr Ferrante's team propose about the lumps of lime?Answer
Answer: C They were produced by a deliberate method of mixing.
Paragraph D: the lumps 'were the result of a deliberate technique, in which quicklime was added directly to the mix'. B is the old explanation the team rejects.
8In paragraph E, the writer points out that Roman concreteAnswer
Answer: A cannot support loads as heavy as modern concrete can.
Paragraph E: it 'cannot carry the enormous loads that modern buildings and bridges require'. B, C and D all contradict the paragraph.
9Why did the Romans build arches and domes of particular shapes?Answer
Answer: D so that the main forces acting on them were compressive
Paragraph E: they shaped structures 'so that the forces acting on them were mainly compressive'. In fact they used 'massive walls', so A is wrong.
10Why does Ferrante think new mixes will take time to be widely used?Answer
Answer: B Building rules require new materials to be tested for many years.
Paragraph G: 'any new material must prove itself over many years before it is approved'. C contradicts the passage: 'Several companies are now testing such mixes'.
The rest of this passage
Other question types on the same text, like the paper.
More Multiple Choice practice
Common questions
Are these real IELTS Reading questions?
No. They're original practice questions written in the official IELTS format and numbering, with answers and explanations. Real test questions aren't published.
How should I use the answers?
Answer every question first, then check. For each one you got wrong, read the explanation and find the line in the passage that gives the answer: that's where the trap or paraphrase is.
Answer it in the app
See right and wrong at once with the reason for each. Free to start, nothing to install.