IELTS Reading · Reading Passage 1
Rooftop hives: yes, no, not given
Yes / No / Not Given practice, questions 1–5, with the full passage and every answer explained. Try the questions first; the answers are folded away below.
- Questions
- 1–5
- Passage
- 741 words
- Level
- Easier
- Part
- 1 of 3 on this passage
The Trouble with Rooftop Hives
ATen years ago, a beehive on a city rooftop was a curiosity. Today, hives sit on the roofs of banks, hotels and department stores in most large European cities, and in London the number of registered colonies is thought to have roughly doubled in a decade. The motive is usually admirable: bees are in trouble, and keeping them seems an obvious way to help. I have come to believe, however, that the rooftop hive has become a symbol rather than a solution, and that in some cities it may be doing more harm than good.
BThe first difficulty is one of identity. The bee that most people picture, the honeybee, is a single domesticated species, managed for its honey in much the same way as a dairy cow is managed for milk. It is not endangered. The species that are declining are mostly wild bees: the bumblebees, mining bees and mason bees, of which Britain alone has more than 250 species. Ecologist Dr Helen Marsh, who has surveyed pollinators in parks and gardens across northern England, points out that adding honeybees to a city does nothing for these wild relatives. “Saving the bees by keeping honeybees,” she says, “is like saving wild birds by keeping chickens.”
CWorse, the two may compete. A strong honeybee colony can contain 50,000 workers in midsummer, and each forager may visit several thousand flowers a day. Where flowers are scarce, as they are in many city centres, wild bees can simply be crowded out. In a three-year study of 30 urban sites, entomologist Tomasz Wilk found that the number of wild bee species recorded fell as the density of nearby hives rose. Wilk is careful to say that his data show a correlation, not proof of cause, but he believes competition for nectar and pollen is the most likely explanation. Honeybees can also carry viruses that spread to wild species when they feed on the same flowers.
DSupporters of urban beekeeping have answers to these points. Priya Raman, who runs a company that installs and manages hives for businesses, argues that rooftop hives raise public awareness of pollinators in a way that no leaflet can. Office workers who watch a colony through a glass panel, she says, often go home and plant flowers in their own gardens. She also disputes Wilk’s conclusions, noting that sites with many hives tend to be in the most built-up districts, where wild bees would be rare anyway. That is a fair criticism, and it shows how difficult this kind of research is. Yet the burden of proof should surely rest with those who are adding a large number of animals to a fragile system, not with those who urge caution.
EThe real constraint is food. A city can only support as many bees as its flowers can feed, and that number is far lower than enthusiasts imagine. A survey of forage in central Paris, carried out by a team of university botanists, estimated that the available flowers could sustain around three colonies per square kilometre. Some districts already had more than ten. Honey yields from rooftop hives in those districts had fallen sharply, which suggests that the bees were going hungry. In my view, any city that encourages beekeeping without first measuring its forage is acting irresponsibly.
FNone of this means that cities are bad places for bees. On the contrary, gardens, railway embankments and cemeteries often hold a greater variety of flowering plants than intensively farmed countryside, and several studies have found wild bees doing well in towns. The lesson is that the most useful thing a city can do is to plant. Councils that leave road verges uncut until late summer, replace bedding plants with native wildflowers and stop spraying weedkiller in parks will help far more species than any number of hives. Marsh has calculated that the cost of maintaining a single managed hive for a year would pay for wildflower planting along roughly half a kilometre of verge.
GShould urban beekeeping therefore be banned? I do not think so. It gives pleasure to many people and, carefully managed, does little damage. But companies that install hives to demonstrate their concern for the environment ought to be honest about what they are doing. A rooftop hive is a hobby, or at best an educational tool. If a business genuinely wishes to help pollinators, it should spend its money on flowers.
Questions 1–5
Do the following statements agree with the claims of the writer in the reading passage? Choose YES if the statement agrees with the claims of the writer, NO if the statement contradicts the claims of the writer, or NOT GIVEN if it is impossible to say what the writer thinks about this.
- 1Rooftop hives have become more of a gesture than an effective response to the decline of bees.
- 2Raman’s objection to Wilk’s research has some merit.
- 3It is the people who warn against urban hives who should have to prove their case.
- 4Wild bees pollinate crops more efficiently than honeybees do.
- 5Keeping bees in cities should be made illegal.
Answers and explanations
Open one at a time to check as you go, or the key to mark them all.
Answer key: Questions 1–5Show
- 1Yes
- 2Yes
- 3No
- 4Not Given
- 5No
1Rooftop hives have become more of a gesture than an effective response to the decline of bees.Answer
Answer: Yes
Paragraph A: “the rooftop hive has become a symbol rather than a solution”. A symbol is a gesture; “rather than a solution” means it is not effective.
2Raman’s objection to Wilk’s research has some merit.Answer
Answer: Yes
Paragraph D: after Raman’s point about built-up districts, the writer says “That is a fair criticism”.
3It is the people who warn against urban hives who should have to prove their case.Answer
Answer: No
Paragraph D: “the burden of proof should surely rest with those who are adding a large number of animals … not with those who urge caution.” The statement reverses this.
4Wild bees pollinate crops more efficiently than honeybees do.Answer
Answer: Not Given
The writer compares wild bees and honeybees as species at risk and as competitors for food, but never says which is the better pollinator. Paragraph F mentions farmed countryside, which tempts a “yes”.
5Keeping bees in cities should be made illegal.Answer
Answer: No
Paragraph G: “Should urban beekeeping therefore be banned? I do not think so.”
The rest of this passage
Other question types on the same text, like the paper.
More Yes / No / Not Given practice
Common questions
Are these real IELTS Reading questions?
No. They're original practice questions written in the official IELTS format and numbering, with answers and explanations. Real test questions aren't published.
How should I use the answers?
Answer every question first, then check. For each one you got wrong, read the explanation and find the line in the passage that gives the answer: that's where the trap or paraphrase is.
What's the difference between False and Not Given?
False (or No) means the passage says the opposite of the statement. Not Given means the passage doesn't say either way, even if the statement sounds likely.
Answer it in the app
See right and wrong at once with the reason for each. Free to start, nothing to install.