IELTS, Writing Task 2
Is prison for punishment or rehabilitation?: sample answer
A model answer to this exam-style IELTS writing task 2 question, written to a Band 8 target. See the question, the full answer and exactly why it works, then try it yourself.
- Task
- Writing Task 2
- Time
- 40 minutes
- Answer length
- 295 words
- Written to
- Band 8 target
The question
Task
Some people think that the main purpose of prison is to punish criminals. Others believe that prisons should focus on helping offenders return to society as law-abiding citizens. Discuss both these views and give your own opinion. Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience. Write at least 250 words.
Sample answer
Linking words are highlighted: they show the structure a rater follows.
There is a long-standing debate about what prisons are actually for. Some see them primarily as places of punishment, while others argue that their chief task should be to transform offenders into law-abiding citizens. Having considered both positions, I believe rehabilitation should be the central aim, although punishment cannot be ignored entirely.
Those who emphasise punishment argue that justice demands it. When someone has committed a serious crime, victims and their families reasonably expect the offender to suffer a consequence proportionate to the harm caused, and a sentence that seems too comfortable can feel like an insult to them. Punishment is also thought to deter others: if prison is unpleasant, potential criminals may decide that breaking the law is not worth the risk. From this perspective, spending money on courses and counselling for prisoners appears to reward wrongdoing.
Supporters of rehabilitation, however, point to what happens after release. Almost all prisoners eventually return to the community, and if they leave without skills, savings or support, many will drift back into crime within a short time. Prisons that offer education, vocational training and treatment for addiction have, in several countries, achieved notably lower reoffending rates. An inmate who gains a qualification in plumbing or catering while serving a sentence has a realistic alternative to crime on release, which ultimately protects the public far more effectively than harsh conditions alone.
In my view, the second argument is the more persuasive because the ultimate purpose of the justice system should be to reduce future crime. Loss of liberty is itself a significant punishment, and the time spent in custody is best used to prepare offenders for a different life. A system built on this principle serves victims too, by ensuring that fewer people become victims in the future.
295 words
Why it works
What you can measure in this answer, and what IELTS examiners mark.
- The right length. 295 words: inside the required 250–320, in 4 paragraphs.
- Clear links between ideas: “however”, “although”, “while”, “because”. They make the answer easy to follow, which raters reward under coherence.
- 4 paragraphs, each with its own job, so the reader can follow the answer at a glance.
How IELTS marks writing task 2
- Task ResponseBand 0–9
Answers every part of the task with relevant, well-supported ideas.
- Coherence & CohesionBand 0–9
Logical paragraphs and linking words that guide the reader.
- Lexical ResourceBand 0–9
A range of vocabulary used accurately and naturally.
- Grammatical Range & AccuracyBand 0–9
A mix of simple and complex sentences with few errors.
Common questions
How many words should a IELTS Writing Task 2 answer have?
The task asks for 250 to 320 words, written in 40 minutes. This sample is 295 words.
How is IELTS Writing Task 2 scored?
IELTS marks it on Task Response, Coherence & Cohesion, Lexical Resource, Grammatical Range & Accuracy, each on a Band 0 to 9 scale. Your result for the task comes from these together.
Is this a real IELTS question?
No. It's an original, exam-style question written to match the official format. Nobody can legally publish real test questions.
Should I memorise this answer?
No. Use it to see the structure, length and linking words that work, then answer in your own words. Memorised answers rarely fit a new question, and IELTS examiners notice relevant, natural answers.
Where can I practice this question and get a score?
Open it on a2zexams: record or type your own answer and get an instant estimated score on each IELTS criterion, with what to fix. It's free to start.
More Writing Task 2 sample answers
- Buy now, pay later: help or trap?Many online shops now allow customers to buy goods immediately and pay for them later in several instalments. Do the…
- Who should cut packaging: shops or shoppers?Some people feel that manufacturers and supermarkets have the responsibility to reduce the amount of packaging of…
- Why trust in public spending is fallingIn many countries, people say they do not trust their government to spend taxpayers' money wisely. Why do you think…
- Can online lessons replace the school classroom?Some people believe that children learn best in a classroom with a teacher. Others think that online lessons at home…
- Should employers pay staff to exercise?Employers should be required to give their staff paid time during the working day to take part in physical exercise. To…
- Who should pay for scientific research?Some people believe that scientific research should be funded mainly by governments. Others think that private…
Now try a writing task 2 question yourself
Write your answer and get an instant estimated IELTS band with what to fix. Free to start, nothing to install.