IELTS Reading · Reading Passage 1
Citizen science: matching people
Matching Features practice, questions 5–9, with the full passage and every answer explained. Try the questions first; the answers are folded away below.
- Questions
- 5–9
- Passage
- 668 words
- Level
- Easier
- Part
- 2 of 3 on this passage
Science for Everyone
AEvery winter, tens of thousands of people across Britain spend an hour looking out of their windows and counting the birds in their gardens. Their results, sent in online, help scientists track the rise and fall of species from house sparrows to goldfinches. Surveys of this kind are among the oldest examples of what is now called citizen science: research in which members of the public collect or analyse data. In my view, it is one of the most valuable developments in modern science, and it is still undervalued by many professional researchers.
BThe idea is not new. Birdwatchers in North America have taken part in an annual Christmas bird count since 1900, and amateur astronomers have been reporting comets and variable stars for even longer. What has changed is the scale. The internet and the smartphone allow millions of people to contribute, often with nothing more than a camera and an app. On one popular astronomy website, volunteers have classified the shapes of more than a million galaxies from telescope images, a task that would have taken professional astronomers decades. In another project, players of an online puzzle game have helped biochemists work out how proteins fold, sometimes finding solutions that had defeated computer programs. Projects now range from counting penguins in satellite photographs to recording the dates on which local trees come into leaf.
CThe ecologist Dr Emma Reid, who coordinates a national butterfly survey, says that volunteers make it possible to collect information over areas far too large for any research team. Her survey relies on around 3,000 people who walk the same route once a week through the summer, recording every butterfly they see. Without them, she says, “we would know almost nothing about how butterflies are responding to climate change”. Reid’s data have shown that several species have moved their ranges northwards by more than 100 kilometres in thirty years.
DThe most common objection is that amateurs make mistakes. A volunteer may confuse two similar species or forget to record a sighting. The data scientist Dr Aisha Bello has studied this problem and found that, although individual volunteers do make errors, these tend to cancel out when large numbers of records are combined. Projects can also build in checks: rare sightings may require a photograph, and experts can review samples of the data. Bello’s research suggests that, with such checks in place, the accuracy of volunteer data approaches that of professional surveys. I believe concerns about quality, while understandable, are often exaggerated.
EVolunteers do not only collect data; sometimes they make discoveries. In 2007 a Dutch schoolteacher taking part in an online galaxy project noticed a strange glowing cloud near a galaxy, an object that professional astronomers had not described before. The astronomer Professor Victor Hall argues that this kind of discovery happens because volunteers look at images with fresh eyes. Unlike computer programs, which find only what they have been trained to find, people notice things that are unexpected.
FCitizen science also benefits the volunteers. Tom Fraser, a retired engineer who has tested water quality in his local river every month for six years, says that the work has taught him more about ecology than any book. When his readings showed a sudden rise in pollution, he reported it to the environmental authorities, who traced it to a leaking pipe at a nearby farm. Many projects report that people who take part become more interested in protecting the environment and more trusting of science.
GNone of this means that citizen science can replace professional research, and I would be concerned if universities or governments saw it as a cheap substitute for paying scientists. Volunteers are best at tasks that need many eyes; they cannot design experiments or interpret complex results without expert help. But as a partnership between scientists and the public, citizen science deserves more support and more recognition. Volunteers who contribute to published research should, at the very least, be thanked by name.
Questions 5–9
Match each statement with the correct person, A, B, C or D. You may use any letter more than once.
- AEmma Reid
- BAisha Bello
- CVictor Hall
- DTom Fraser
- 5found that errors made by individuals become less important in large data sets
- 6helped to identify the cause of a pollution incident
- 7explains why people may spot things that computers miss
- 8has used volunteers’ records to show that species are changing where they live
- 9believes that volunteers allow research to cover much larger areas
Answers and explanations
Open one at a time to check as you go, or the key to mark them all.
Answer key: Questions 5–9Show
- 5B Aisha Bello
- 6D Tom Fraser
- 7C Victor Hall
- 8A Emma Reid
- 9A Emma Reid
5found that errors made by individuals become less important in large data setsAnswer
Answer: B Aisha Bello
Paragraph D: Bello found that errors “tend to cancel out when large numbers of records are combined”.
6helped to identify the cause of a pollution incidentAnswer
Answer: D Tom Fraser
Paragraph F: Fraser reported a rise in pollution, which the authorities “traced … to a leaking pipe at a nearby farm”.
7explains why people may spot things that computers missAnswer
Answer: C Victor Hall
Paragraph E: Hall says computer programs “find only what they have been trained to find” while people “notice things that are unexpected”.
8has used volunteers’ records to show that species are changing where they liveAnswer
Answer: A Emma Reid
Paragraph C: “Reid’s data have shown that several species have moved their ranges northwards.”
9believes that volunteers allow research to cover much larger areasAnswer
Answer: A Emma Reid
Paragraph C: volunteers make it possible “to collect information over areas far too large for any research team”.
The rest of this passage
Other question types on the same text, like the paper.
More Matching Features practice
Common questions
Are these real IELTS Reading questions?
No. They're original practice questions written in the official IELTS format and numbering, with answers and explanations. Real test questions aren't published.
How should I use the answers?
Answer every question first, then check. For each one you got wrong, read the explanation and find the line in the passage that gives the answer: that's where the trap or paraphrase is.
Answer it in the app
See right and wrong at once with the reason for each. Free to start, nothing to install.