IELTS Reading · Reading Passage 2
Do fish feel pain: matching scientists
Matching Features practice, questions 18–21, with the full passage and every answer explained. Try the questions first; the answers are folded away below.
- Questions
- 18–21
- Passage
- 681 words
- Level
- Medium
- Part
- 2 of 3 on this passage
Do Fish Feel Pain?
AFew people would hesitate to say that a dog or a horse can feel pain. Many are far less sure about fish. Fish do not cry out, their faces cannot change expression, and they live in a world so unlike ours that it is hard to imagine what they experience. For centuries, this uncertainty allowed people to treat fish as though their suffering did not matter, or did not exist. Over the past twenty-five years, however, scientists have argued fiercely about the question, and I believe the weight of evidence has now shifted decisively.
BMuch of the modern debate began with experiments by the biologist Lynne Sneddon in the early 2000s. Sneddon first identified nociceptors, the nerve endings that detect damaging stimuli, in the faces and mouths of rainbow trout. She then injected a mild irritant into the lips of some fish and found that they behaved abnormally: they rocked from side to side, rubbed their lips against the gravel of their tank and took far longer than usual to resume feeding. When the fish were given morphine, a painkiller, these behaviours were greatly reduced. This, Sneddon argued, was what one would expect if the fish were experiencing something like pain, rather than simply reacting by reflex.
CNot everyone accepted this interpretation. The neuroscientist Brian Key has argued that feeling pain requires particular brain structures, similar to the human cerebral cortex, that fish do not possess. On this view, a fish may detect damage and respond to it, just as a plant may turn towards light, without any conscious experience of suffering. Key’s argument is carefully made, and it reminds us that behaviour alone cannot prove what an animal feels. But I find it unconvincing. Birds also lack a cortex like ours, yet few scientists now doubt that birds can feel pain; different brains may simply reach the same result by different routes.
DOther researchers have approached the question by asking how intelligent fish are. The biologist Culum Brown has reviewed a wide range of studies and concluded that fish are far more capable than their reputation suggests. Some species recognise individual companions, learn by watching others and remember the layout of their surroundings for months. Some wrasse use rocks to crack open shellfish, a form of tool use once thought to be confined to mammals and birds. Brown argues that animals with such complex minds are likely to have complex experiences, including pain.
EThe law has begun to follow the science. In 2022 the United Kingdom passed legislation formally recognising that all vertebrate animals, including fish, are sentient, along with octopuses, crabs and lobsters. The practical consequences are still unclear. Fish farming, in which millions of fish are kept in crowded pens and are often killed by methods that would be illegal for cattle or chickens, is the area where I believe change is most urgently needed. Methods that stun fish quickly before slaughter already exist, and some producers have adopted them. Others have resisted, arguing that the equipment is costly to install. Since farmed fish are counted not in thousands but in billions each year, even small improvements in how they are handled could prevent suffering on an enormous scale.
FAngling raises harder questions. Millions of people fish for pleasure, many of them returning their catch to the water alive. Some anglers argue that a fish released quickly suffers little lasting harm, and there is evidence that careful handling and barbless hooks reduce injury. I do not think that angling should be banned, but I think anglers who accept the evidence have a duty to handle fish as gently as possible and to keep them out of the water for as short a time as they can.
GWe may never know exactly what it is like to be a fish. But certainty is not required before we act. If there is good reason to think that an animal can suffer, and in my view there now is, then the burden lies on us to avoid causing that suffering where we reasonably can.
Questions 18–21
Match each statement with the correct scientist, A, B or C. You may use any letter more than once.
- ALynne Sneddon
- BBrian Key
- CCulum Brown
- 18found that a drug reduced unusual behaviour in fish
- 19argues that fish lack the brain structures needed to experience pain
- 20links the mental abilities of fish to the likelihood that they feel pain
- 21located nerve endings that respond to harmful stimuli
Answers and explanations
Open one at a time to check as you go, or the key to mark them all.
Answer key: Questions 18–21Show
- 18A Lynne Sneddon
- 19B Brian Key
- 20C Culum Brown
- 21A Lynne Sneddon
18found that a drug reduced unusual behaviour in fishAnswer
Answer: A Lynne Sneddon
Paragraph B: “When the fish were given morphine, a painkiller, these behaviours were greatly reduced.”
19argues that fish lack the brain structures needed to experience painAnswer
Answer: B Brian Key
Paragraph C: Key argues that pain requires structures similar to the human cerebral cortex “that fish do not possess”.
20links the mental abilities of fish to the likelihood that they feel painAnswer
Answer: C Culum Brown
Paragraph D: Brown argues “that animals with such complex minds are likely to have complex experiences, including pain”.
21located nerve endings that respond to harmful stimuliAnswer
Answer: A Lynne Sneddon
Paragraph B: Sneddon “first identified nociceptors, the nerve endings that detect damaging stimuli”.
The rest of this passage
Other question types on the same text, like the paper.
More Matching Features practice
Common questions
Are these real IELTS Reading questions?
No. They're original practice questions written in the official IELTS format and numbering, with answers and explanations. Real test questions aren't published.
How should I use the answers?
Answer every question first, then check. For each one you got wrong, read the explanation and find the line in the passage that gives the answer: that's where the trap or paraphrase is.
Answer it in the app
See right and wrong at once with the reason for each. Free to start, nothing to install.