IELTS Reading · Reading Passage 2
Restore or repair: matching people
Matching Features practice, questions 19–23, with the full passage and every answer explained. Try the questions first; the answers are folded away below.
- Questions
- 19–23
- Passage
- 703 words
- Level
- Medium
- Part
- 2 of 3 on this passage
Restore or Repair?
AFew questions divide those who care for old buildings as sharply as this one: when a cathedral or castle has decayed, should it be repaired so that it looks as it once did, or merely kept from falling down? The question is not new. It was fought over with great passion in the nineteenth century, and the answers given then still shape the way historic buildings are treated today.
BThe most ambitious restorer of the age was the French architect Eugène Viollet-le-Duc. From the 1840s onwards he worked on many of France’s great medieval buildings, including the cathedral of Notre-Dame in Paris, for which he designed a new spire to replace one that had been removed in the late eighteenth century, and the walled city of Carcassonne in the south. His approach was bold. In a famous definition, he wrote that to restore a building was not to maintain or repair it, but to return it to a state of completeness that might never have existed at any one time. If a medieval architect had left a building unfinished, the restorer could finish it as he believed the original builders would have done.
CAt Carcassonne this produced results that are still disputed. Viollet-le-Duc gave the towers steep, pointed roofs of slate, a style common in northern France, although critics argue that the builders of the south would have used flatter roofs covered in tiles. Visitors today see a fortress that looks more complete than it ever did in the Middle Ages. I confess that I find it thrilling, and I suspect most visitors do too. But it is not, in any strict sense, a medieval building; it is a nineteenth-century idea of one.
DIn England, the strongest opposition to this kind of work came from the critic John Ruskin. In The Seven Lamps of Architecture, published in 1849, he described restoration as the most total destruction a building could suffer, and as “a lie from beginning to end”. The value of an old building, Ruskin believed, lay in the marks left by time and by the hands of the people who had made it. Replace the worn stones with new ones, however accurate, and that value was lost for ever. His advice was simple: look after buildings properly, and they would never need to be restored.
ERuskin’s ideas were turned into a campaign by the designer William Morris. Angered by plans to restore Tewkesbury Abbey, Morris founded the Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings in 1877. Its manifesto called for “protection in place of restoration”: repairs should be carried out only where necessary, and in a way that made no attempt to disguise them. The Society still exists, and its principles, sometimes summed up as “conservative repair”, are followed by many architects in Britain today.
FRuskin and Morris won the argument, at least among professionals. In 1964 the Venice Charter, an international agreement on the treatment of historic monuments, declared that restoration must stop at the point where conjecture begins, and that any new work must be distinguishable from the original. Yet I am not sure their victory was complete. Ruskin’s position, taken to its logical end, would leave many buildings to collapse rather than allow any new material to be added, and even Morris’s Society has always accepted that some replacement is unavoidable. The real disagreement is not between restoration and no restoration, but about how much is done and in what spirit.
GThe fire that destroyed the roof and spire of Notre-Dame in 2019 brought these old arguments back to life. Some architects proposed a modern spire of glass or steel; others insisted that the building be rebuilt exactly as it had been before the fire. In the end, the French authorities chose to reconstruct Viollet-le-Duc’s spire. Purists objected that this meant copying a nineteenth-century invention rather than anything medieval. I think the decision was right. After more than 150 years, the spire had become part of the cathedral’s history in its own right, and its loss was mourned as such. A building, as Ruskin himself understood, carries the marks of every age that has cared for it, including those of its restorers.
Questions 19–23
Match each statement with the correct person or document, A, B, C or D. You may use any letter more than once.
- AEugène Viollet-le-Duc
- BJohn Ruskin
- CWilliam Morris
- Dthe Venice Charter
- 19stated that restoration should not be based on guesswork
- 20believed a restorer could complete what the original builders had left unfinished
- 21saw the signs of age on a building as the source of its worth
- 22was provoked into action by a scheme for one particular building
- 23claimed that buildings which were well maintained would never need restoring
Answers and explanations
Open one at a time to check as you go, or the key to mark them all.
Answer key: Questions 19–23Show
- 19D the Venice Charter
- 20A Eugène Viollet-le-Duc
- 21B John Ruskin
- 22C William Morris
- 23B John Ruskin
19stated that restoration should not be based on guessworkAnswer
Answer: D the Venice Charter
Paragraph F: the Venice Charter “declared that restoration must stop at the point where conjecture begins”.
20believed a restorer could complete what the original builders had left unfinishedAnswer
Answer: A Eugène Viollet-le-Duc
Paragraph B: “If a medieval architect had left a building unfinished, the restorer could finish it.”
21saw the signs of age on a building as the source of its worthAnswer
Answer: B John Ruskin
Paragraph D: Ruskin believed the value “lay in the marks left by time and by the hands of the people who had made it”.
22was provoked into action by a scheme for one particular buildingAnswer
Answer: C William Morris
Paragraph E: “Angered by plans to restore Tewkesbury Abbey, Morris founded the Society.”
23claimed that buildings which were well maintained would never need restoringAnswer
Answer: B John Ruskin
Paragraph D: “look after buildings properly, and they would never need to be restored.”
The rest of this passage
Other question types on the same text, like the paper.
More Matching Features practice
Common questions
Are these real IELTS Reading questions?
No. They're original practice questions written in the official IELTS format and numbering, with answers and explanations. Real test questions aren't published.
How should I use the answers?
Answer every question first, then check. For each one you got wrong, read the explanation and find the line in the passage that gives the answer: that's where the trap or paraphrase is.
Answer it in the app
See right and wrong at once with the reason for each. Free to start, nothing to install.