IELTS Reading · Reading Passage 3
Dating the Clay: multiple choice
Multiple Choice practice, questions 32–35, with the full passage and every answer explained. Try the questions first; the answers are folded away below.
- Questions
- 32–35
- Passage
- 723 words
- Level
- Harder
- Part
- 2 of 3 on this passage
Dating the Clay
ARadiocarbon dating, the best-known method of establishing the age of archaeological material, has one important limitation: it works only on things that were once alive, such as wood, bone or seeds. For pottery, which is among the most abundant finds at many sites, archaeologists long had to rely on indirect evidence, dating a pot by the objects found near it or by comparing its style with others whose age was already known. Since the 1960s, however, a technique known as thermoluminescence has made it possible to date the clay itself.
BThe method depends on a property of certain minerals, notably quartz and feldspar, which are present in almost all clays. Buried objects are exposed to a constant low level of natural radiation, from radioactive elements in the surrounding soil and, to a lesser extent, from cosmic rays. This radiation dislodges electrons within the mineral crystals, and some of them become caught in tiny defects in the crystal structure, where they remain. Over time, therefore, the number of trapped electrons grows steadily. When the material is heated strongly, the electrons escape, and as they do so they give off a faint glow of light. The amount of light is proportional to the number of electrons that had been trapped.
CCrucially, the firing of a pot in a kiln empties all the traps, setting what is in effect a clock back to zero. From that moment, electrons begin to accumulate again. To date a piece, a laboratory removes a small sample of powder, usually by drilling into an inconspicuous part of the object, heats it under controlled conditions and measures the light emitted. This reveals the total dose of radiation the sample has received since it was fired. If the dose the object receives each year is also known, dividing one figure by the other gives its age.
DEstablishing that annual dose is the most difficult part of the process. It depends on the concentration of radioactive elements both in the pot itself and in the soil in which it was buried, and on how much water the soil contained, since water absorbs part of the radiation. Ideally, measurements are taken at the site where the object was found, using samples of the surrounding earth. For objects with no recorded find-spot, such as many pieces held in museum collections, this is impossible, and the dose must be estimated, which considerably widens the margin of error. Even under good conditions, the method is less precise than radiocarbon dating, with typical uncertainties of five to ten per cent of the age.
EDespite this, thermoluminescence has had a striking impact in one area where precision matters less: the detection of forgeries. A ceramic that is claimed to be two thousand years old but was in fact made in the last century will have accumulated only a tiny fraction of the expected dose. In the 1970s, tests on a celebrated group of supposedly prehistoric painted pots, which had been bought by museums around the world, showed that many of them were modern. The method does not tell an expert whether an object is genuine in every respect, but it can show conclusively when a piece is far too young. Forgers have responded by exposing new pieces to artificial radiation, although specialists say such tampering can usually be detected through other tests.
FA related technique, optically stimulated luminescence, works on the same principle but uses light rather than heat to release the trapped electrons. Because sunlight also empties the traps, the method can date the last time grains of sand or silt were exposed to daylight before being buried. This has made it valuable for dating sediments, such as the layers of a cave floor, that contain no material suitable for radiocarbon dating. The archaeologist Dr Margaret Ellison, who has used it to date early human sites, notes that it can reach back far beyond the roughly fifty-thousand-year limit of radiocarbon.
GEllison cautions, though, that luminescence methods are only as reliable as the assumptions behind them. If a grain was not fully exposed to light before burial, or if a pot was reheated in a later fire, the apparent age will be wrong. 'The physics is straightforward,' she says. 'What is difficult is the history of the object, which we must always reconstruct.'
Questions 32–35
Choose the correct letter, A, B, C or D.
- 32According to paragraph C, what is the effect of firing a pot in a kiln? A It fills the traps in the crystals with electrons. B It removes the radioactive elements from the clay. C It empties the traps so that the count starts again from zero. D It makes the pot glow for many years afterwards.
- 33Why are objects in museum collections often harder to date accurately? A Their annual radiation dose has to be estimated rather than measured. B They have usually been cleaned with water. C Too little powder can be removed from them. D They were fired at lower temperatures.
- 34Why is thermoluminescence particularly useful for detecting forgeries? A It is more precise than radiocarbon dating. B Forgers have no way of altering the result. C A recently made object shows far less accumulated radiation than an ancient one. D It proves that an object is genuine in every respect.
- 35What does Dr Ellison say about optically stimulated luminescence? A It uses heat rather than light. B It can date sediments far older than radiocarbon can. C It works only on pottery. D It is more reliable than thermoluminescence.
Answers and explanations
Open one at a time to check as you go, or the key to mark them all.
Answer key: Questions 32–35Show
- 32C It empties the traps so that the count starts again from zero.
- 33A Their annual radiation dose has to be estimated rather than measured.
- 34C A recently made object shows far less accumulated radiation than an ancient one.
- 35B It can date sediments far older than radiocarbon can.
32According to paragraph C, what is the effect of firing a pot in a kiln?Answer
Answer: C It empties the traps so that the count starts again from zero.
Paragraph C: firing 'empties all the traps, setting what is in effect a clock back to zero'. A reverses the effect; the glow (D) happens only when a sample is heated in the laboratory.
33Why are objects in museum collections often harder to date accurately?Answer
Answer: A Their annual radiation dose has to be estimated rather than measured.
Paragraph D: without a find-spot, measuring the surrounding soil 'is impossible, and the dose must be estimated, which considerably widens the margin of error'.
34Why is thermoluminescence particularly useful for detecting forgeries?Answer
Answer: C A recently made object shows far less accumulated radiation than an ancient one.
Paragraph E: a modern piece 'will have accumulated only a tiny fraction of the expected dose'. A is wrong (it is 'less precise'), B is wrong because forgers use 'artificial radiation', and D is directly contradicted.
35What does Dr Ellison say about optically stimulated luminescence?Answer
Answer: B It can date sediments far older than radiocarbon can.
Paragraph F: it 'can reach back far beyond the roughly fifty-thousand-year limit of radiocarbon'. It uses 'light rather than heat', and is valuable for 'sediments', so A and C are wrong.
The rest of this passage
Other question types on the same text, like the paper.
More Multiple Choice practice
Common questions
Are these real IELTS Reading questions?
No. They're original practice questions written in the official IELTS format and numbering, with answers and explanations. Real test questions aren't published.
How should I use the answers?
Answer every question first, then check. For each one you got wrong, read the explanation and find the line in the passage that gives the answer: that's where the trap or paraphrase is.
Answer it in the app
See right and wrong at once with the reason for each. Free to start, nothing to install.