Skip to content

IELTS Reading · Reading Passage 3

The bilingual advantage: yes, no, not given

Yes / No / Not Given practice, questions 27–31, with the full passage and every answer explained. Try the questions first; the answers are folded away below.

Questions
27–31
Passage
662 words
Level
Harder
Part
1 of 3 on this passage

The Bilingual Advantage

AFor much of the twentieth century, parents were warned that bringing up a child with two languages would cause confusion. Early studies, many carried out on immigrant children in poorly funded schools, appeared to show that bilingual pupils lagged behind their monolingual classmates on intelligence tests. In 1962, however, a study of schoolchildren in Montreal by Elizabeth Peal and Wallace Lambert found that bilinguals outperformed monolinguals on a range of verbal and non-verbal measures, and the notion of a “bilingual advantage” was born.

BOver the following decades the claim grew more specific. Because bilinguals must constantly suppress one language while using the other, researchers proposed, they develop stronger executive functions: the mental skills that allow us to ignore distractions, switch between tasks and hold information in mind. Laboratory work appeared to confirm this. The psychologist Dr Anna Kovac reported that bilingual children were faster on tasks requiring them to sort cards first by colour and then by shape, and later studies by Kovac and others suggested that lifelong bilingualism might delay the onset of dementia symptoms by several years.

CIt is easy to see why these findings were welcomed. They offered scientific support to immigrant families who wished to keep their heritage language alive, and a selling point to schools offering bilingual education. I confess that I was among those who repeated them uncritically. In the past fifteen years, though, the bilingual advantage has become one of the most bitterly contested ideas in psychology, and I now think that the original claim, at least in its strong form, is very probably wrong.

DThe trouble began with replication. Daniel Ferreira, a cognitive scientist who has repeated many of the classic experiments with samples of several hundred participants rather than the twenty or thirty typical of earlier work, found no consistent difference between bilinguals and monolinguals on any of the standard tasks. At the same time, a review by Sofia Lindgren of studies presented at academic conferences found that those reporting an advantage were far more likely to be published in journals than those reporting none. The literature, in other words, had been filtered, and what reached print gave a misleadingly positive impression.

EDefenders of the advantage reply that the critics have looked in the wrong places. Kovac argues that bilingualism is not a single experience: a child who uses two languages every day at home and at school differs from an adult who learnt a second language at university. Large studies that lump these groups together, she says, are bound to dilute genuine effects. This is a reasonable point, but it carries a cost. If the advantage appears only in particular groups, under particular conditions, on particular tasks, then it is a far smaller and less interesting claim than the one originally made.

FA further problem is that bilingual and monolingual groups rarely differ only in the number of languages they speak. They may differ in income, education, immigration history and the kind of schools they attend, any of which might affect performance on a test. Ferreira has pointed out that in several early studies the bilingual children came from noticeably wealthier families than the monolingual ones. The sociolinguist Ravi Menon goes further, arguing that the whole debate has been a distraction: the real value of a second language, in his view, lies not in faster card-sorting but in access to relatives, communities, literature and work.

GMenon’s argument strikes me as the most persuasive contribution to the entire controversy. Parents should not raise their children with two languages in the hope of making them cleverer; the evidence does not support that hope, and it is not needed. Nor should anyone conclude that the old fears were right after all. Nothing in the recent research suggests that bilingualism holds children back. The case for it never really depended on the laboratory, and it is all the stronger for being freed from claims that could not be sustained.

Questions 27–31

Do the following statements agree with the claims of the writer in the reading passage? Choose YES if the statement agrees with the claims of the writer, NO if the statement contradicts the claims of the writer, or NOT GIVEN if it is impossible to say what the writer thinks about this.

  1. 27The writer used to accept the bilingual advantage without questioning it.
  2. 28The bilingual advantage, as first described, may well turn out to be accurate.
  3. 29Limiting the advantage to certain groups and tasks makes it a less significant claim.
  4. 30Research on bilingual adults is more trustworthy than research on bilingual children.
  5. 31Recent research suggests that bilingualism may slow children’s development.

Answers and explanations

Open one at a time to check as you go, or the key to mark them all.

Answer key: Questions 27–31Show
  1. 27Yes
  2. 28No
  3. 29Yes
  4. 30Not Given
  5. 31No
27The writer used to accept the bilingual advantage without questioning it.Answer

Answer: Yes

Paragraph C: “I confess that I was among those who repeated them uncritically.”

28The bilingual advantage, as first described, may well turn out to be accurate.Answer

Answer: No

Paragraph C: the writer thinks “the original claim, at least in its strong form, is very probably wrong”.

29Limiting the advantage to certain groups and tasks makes it a less significant claim.Answer

Answer: Yes

Paragraph E: if the advantage appears only in particular groups “then it is a far smaller and less interesting claim than the one originally made”. The writer accepts Kovac’s point is “reasonable” but adds this cost.

30Research on bilingual adults is more trustworthy than research on bilingual children.Answer

Answer: Not Given

Paragraph E contrasts children and adults as different kinds of bilingual, but the writer never says which research is more reliable.

31Recent research suggests that bilingualism may slow children’s development.Answer

Answer: No

Paragraph G: “Nothing in the recent research suggests that bilingualism holds children back.” The old fear is mentioned in paragraph A but rejected.

The rest of this passage

Other question types on the same text, like the paper.

More Yes / No / Not Given practice

Common questions

Are these real IELTS Reading questions?

No. They're original practice questions written in the official IELTS format and numbering, with answers and explanations. Real test questions aren't published.

How should I use the answers?

Answer every question first, then check. For each one you got wrong, read the explanation and find the line in the passage that gives the answer: that's where the trap or paraphrase is.

What's the difference between False and Not Given?

False (or No) means the passage says the opposite of the statement. Not Given means the passage doesn't say either way, even if the statement sounds likely.

Answer it in the app

See right and wrong at once with the reason for each. Free to start, nothing to install.