IELTS Reading · Reading Passage 3
Tidal energy: yes, no, not given
Yes / No / Not Given practice, questions 27–30, with the full passage and every answer explained. Try the questions first; the answers are folded away below.
- Questions
- 27–30
- Passage
- 707 words
- Level
- Harder
- Part
- 1 of 3 on this passage
Power from the Tides
AOf all the renewable sources of energy, the tide has one quality that the others lack: it is completely predictable. The wind may drop for days and the sun disappears every night, but the rise and fall of the sea, driven by the pull of the Moon and the Sun, can be calculated years in advance. For an electricity system that must balance supply and demand at every moment, this is a priceless advantage. It is all the more puzzling, then, that tidal power still supplies only a tiny fraction of the world’s electricity. Having followed the industry for many years, I believe the reasons are mostly financial, and partly a failure of nerve.
BThe oldest large tidal power station is at La Rance in Brittany, in north-west France, which opened in 1966 and is still operating. It works on the barrage principle: a dam is built across an estuary, water is held behind it as the tide turns, and the difference in height between the two sides drives turbines in the dam. The largest station of this kind, at Sihwa Lake in South Korea, came about almost by accident. A sea wall built for land reclamation and flood control had made the lake behind it badly polluted, and turbines were installed partly to let the tide flush the water through.
CBarrages work best where the tidal range, the difference between high and low water, is greatest. The Severn Estuary between England and Wales has one of the largest tidal ranges in the world, and plans for a barrage there have been proposed repeatedly for more than a century. They have always been abandoned, partly because of the enormous cost of construction and partly because a barrage would flood the mudflats on which hundreds of thousands of wading birds feed. The ecologist Dr Fiona Hart, who has studied the estuary’s birds for twenty years, argues that no amount of clean energy could justify such a loss.
DAn alternative is the tidal lagoon, a wall built in a loop out from the shore rather than across a whole estuary, which would cause far less disruption. In 2018, however, the British government rejected a proposal for a lagoon at Swansea Bay, judging that the electricity it produced would be too expensive compared with other sources. The energy economist Professor Alan Rhys argues that this judgement was short-sighted. A lagoon, he points out, could last for 120 years, far longer than a wind farm, and its cost should be measured over that whole lifetime rather than the first few decades. I share his view. Decisions about structures that will last for a century should not be made on a spreadsheet designed for twenty years.
EA third approach avoids walls altogether. Tidal stream turbines, which resemble underwater wind turbines, are placed on the seabed in channels where the tide flows fast. Off the north coast of Scotland, in the Pentland Firth, an array of such turbines began sending electricity to the grid in 2016. The engineer Dr Kirsty Moffat, who helped to install them, says that the greatest challenge was not the design of the turbines but the conditions: strong currents leave only short periods each day when divers and vessels can work safely, and salt water corrodes equipment quickly.
FTidal stream power is still expensive, but its costs are falling, as those of wind and solar power fell before it. Moffat believes that, with enough orders, turbine makers could cut costs in half within a decade. I am cautiously optimistic. The environmental effects of turbines appear to be small, although Hart warns that we still know little about how seals and porpoises respond to them.
GNone of these technologies will replace wind or solar power, which are cheaper and can be built almost anywhere. But a power system made up only of wind and sun needs something to fill the gaps when the weather fails, and at present that is usually gas. The tide, which never fails to turn, could fill some of those gaps. It seems to me that a country with long coastlines and strong tides that refuses to invest in tidal power is ignoring one of its greatest natural assets.
Questions 27–30
Do the following statements agree with the claims of the writer in the reading passage? Choose YES if the statement agrees with the claims of the writer, NO if the statement contradicts the claims of the writer, or NOT GIVEN if it is impossible to say what the writer thinks about this.
- 27Tidal power has failed to develop mainly because of technical problems.
- 28The cost of a lagoon should be judged over the full period it would operate.
- 29Tidal stream turbines will be cheaper than wind turbines within ten years.
- 30Countries with suitable coasts are wrong not to invest in tidal power.
Answers and explanations
Open one at a time to check as you go, or the key to mark them all.
Answer key: Questions 27–30Show
- 27No
- 28Yes
- 29Not Given
- 30Yes
27Tidal power has failed to develop mainly because of technical problems.Answer
Answer: No
Paragraph A: the writer believes “the reasons are mostly financial, and partly a failure of nerve”. Technical challenges appear later but are not given as the main reason.
28The cost of a lagoon should be judged over the full period it would operate.Answer
Answer: Yes
Paragraph D: Rhys says the cost “should be measured over that whole lifetime”, and the writer adds “I share his view.”
29Tidal stream turbines will be cheaper than wind turbines within ten years.Answer
Answer: Not Given
Paragraph F: Moffat thinks turbine costs could halve within a decade, but neither she nor the writer compares them with the future cost of wind turbines.
30Countries with suitable coasts are wrong not to invest in tidal power.Answer
Answer: Yes
Paragraph G: such a country “is ignoring one of its greatest natural assets”.
The rest of this passage
Other question types on the same text, like the paper.
More Yes / No / Not Given practice
Common questions
Are these real IELTS Reading questions?
No. They're original practice questions written in the official IELTS format and numbering, with answers and explanations. Real test questions aren't published.
How should I use the answers?
Answer every question first, then check. For each one you got wrong, read the explanation and find the line in the passage that gives the answer: that's where the trap or paraphrase is.
What's the difference between False and Not Given?
False (or No) means the passage says the opposite of the statement. Not Given means the passage doesn't say either way, even if the statement sounds likely.
Answer it in the app
See right and wrong at once with the reason for each. Free to start, nothing to install.