IELTS Reading · Reading Passage 2
De-extinction: yes, no, not given
Yes / No / Not Given practice, questions 14–18, with the full passage and every answer explained. Try the questions first; the answers are folded away below.
- Questions
- 14–18
- Passage
- 670 words
- Level
- Medium
- Part
- 1 of 3 on this passage
Bringing Back the Mammoth
AIn the last few years, the idea of bringing extinct animals back to life has moved from science fiction into the business plans of private companies. One firm has announced that it intends to produce an animal resembling the woolly mammoth by editing the genes of the Asian elephant, its closest living relative; others have spoken of reviving the passenger pigeon, the thylacine and even the dodo. The public response has been largely delighted. Mine has been more mixed. I find the science fascinating, but I am unconvinced that it is the best use of money that might otherwise protect species that are still alive.
BIt is worth being clear about what de-extinction actually means. No extinct animal can be recreated exactly. DNA breaks down after death, and even the best-preserved mammoth remains, recovered from the Siberian permafrost, yield only fragments of the genome. What scientists propose instead is to take a living relative and alter a small number of its genes so that it acquires some of the extinct animal’s characteristics: a thick coat, a layer of fat, smaller ears. The geneticist Dr Karin Holt, who works on gene editing in livestock, describes the likely result frankly as “a cold-adapted elephant, not a mammoth”. In my view, this distinction is too often lost in press coverage.
CSupporters argue that such animals could restore lost ecological functions. Mammoths once grazed the northern steppe, trampling snow and knocking down trees, which kept the ground cold and encouraged grass to grow. The ecologist Pavel Orlov, who manages an experimental reserve in northern Siberia stocked with horses, bison and reindeer, believes that large grazers could slow the thawing of permafrost, which releases carbon as it melts. His measurements show that in winter the soil in grazed areas is several degrees colder than outside the fence, because the animals compress the snow that would otherwise insulate the ground.
DThis is an intriguing idea, and Orlov’s results deserve to be taken seriously. Yet they also undermine the case for mammoths. If horses and bison can do the job, there seems little reason to spend decades engineering a new animal to do it. Moreover, an elephant-based animal would reproduce slowly: elephants are pregnant for around 22 months, and a herd large enough to change a landscape would take generations to build.
EThe strongest objection is financial. The conservation economist Dr Amara Nwosu has estimated that the money pledged to a single de-extinction project could fund the protection of several hundred threatened species for a decade. Defenders reply that this money comes from private investors who would never have given it to conservation charities, so nothing is being taken away. That may be so, but it misses a subtler danger. The ethicist Professor Simon Reeve warns that if the public comes to believe that extinction is reversible, the pressure to prevent it may weaken. I share this fear. A government under pressure to approve a new mine or motorway could be tempted to treat the loss of a species as a temporary setback.
FThere are, however, parts of this research that I would welcome. The same tools could help species that survive in dangerously small numbers. In the United States, a black-footed ferret was cloned from cells that had been frozen more than thirty years earlier, adding genetic variety to a population descended from only a handful of animals. Holt’s own laboratory is now using gene editing to restore lost genetic diversity in a rare breed of cattle, and she believes the same methods could one day make frogs resistant to the fungal disease that has devastated amphibians worldwide.
GI would not ban de-extinction research, and the mammoth may prove a powerful way of drawing young people into science. But we should judge it as we judge any conservation spending: by what it achieves for the species we still have. Measured that way, a modified elephant on the Siberian steppe looks less like a rescue than a very expensive spectacle.
Questions 14–18
Do the following statements agree with the claims of the writer in the reading passage? Choose YES if the statement agrees with the claims of the writer, NO if the statement contradicts the claims of the writer, or NOT GIVEN if it is impossible to say what the writer thinks about this.
- 14The writer shares the general public’s delight at plans to revive extinct species.
- 15News reports often fail to make clear that a revived animal would not be the original species.
- 16Orlov’s findings strengthen the argument for recreating mammoths.
- 17A modified elephant would struggle to survive the Siberian winter.
- 18Believing that extinction can be reversed might make people less determined to prevent it.
Answers and explanations
Open one at a time to check as you go, or the key to mark them all.
Answer key: Questions 14–18Show
- 14No
- 15Yes
- 16No
- 17Not Given
- 18Yes
14The writer shares the general public’s delight at plans to revive extinct species.Answer
Answer: No
Paragraph A: “The public response has been largely delighted. Mine has been more mixed.”
15News reports often fail to make clear that a revived animal would not be the original species.Answer
Answer: Yes
Paragraph B: after Holt’s “a cold-adapted elephant, not a mammoth”, the writer says “this distinction is too often lost in press coverage”.
16Orlov’s findings strengthen the argument for recreating mammoths.Answer
Answer: No
Paragraph D: Orlov’s results “deserve to be taken seriously. Yet they also undermine the case for mammoths.”
17A modified elephant would struggle to survive the Siberian winter.Answer
Answer: Not Given
The passage describes the animal as “cold-adapted” and notes it would breed slowly, but the writer never says whether it would survive the winter.
18Believing that extinction can be reversed might make people less determined to prevent it.Answer
Answer: Yes
Paragraph E: Reeve warns that pressure to prevent extinction may weaken, and the writer says “I share this fear.”
The rest of this passage
Other question types on the same text, like the paper.
More Yes / No / Not Given practice
Common questions
Are these real IELTS Reading questions?
No. They're original practice questions written in the official IELTS format and numbering, with answers and explanations. Real test questions aren't published.
How should I use the answers?
Answer every question first, then check. For each one you got wrong, read the explanation and find the line in the passage that gives the answer: that's where the trap or paraphrase is.
What's the difference between False and Not Given?
False (or No) means the passage says the opposite of the statement. Not Given means the passage doesn't say either way, even if the statement sounds likely.
Answer it in the app
See right and wrong at once with the reason for each. Free to start, nothing to install.