IELTS Reading · Reading Passage 2
Roman concrete: yes, no, not given
Yes / No / Not Given practice, questions 14–17, with the full passage and every answer explained. Try the questions first; the answers are folded away below.
- Questions
- 14–17
- Passage
- 675 words
- Level
- Medium
- Part
- 1 of 3 on this passage
The Secret of Roman Concrete
ANearly two thousand years after it was built, the dome of the Pantheon in Rome remains the largest dome of unreinforced concrete in the world. Roman harbour walls, built of concrete poured directly into the sea, still stand along the coasts of the Mediterranean, while many modern concrete structures begin to crumble within fifty years. It is not surprising, then, that Roman concrete has acquired an almost mythical reputation. Newspaper articles regularly announce that the Romans knew a secret that modern engineers have forgotten. I think the truth is both more interesting and more modest than that.
BThe basic ingredients were described in the first century BCE by the Roman architect Vitruvius. Roman builders mixed lime with a volcanic ash found around the Bay of Naples, which they called pulvis puteolanus after the town of Puteoli, and added chunks of rock or broken brick. For structures built in the sea, Vitruvius recommended a mixture of two parts ash to one part lime, packed into wooden frames that had been lowered into the water. The ash was the key. When it reacted with lime and water, it formed a material that set hard even underwater.
CRecent research has shown why this material has lasted so long. The geologist Dr Livia Conti analysed cores drilled from ancient harbour walls and found that seawater, seeping slowly through the concrete over centuries, had reacted with the volcanic ash to grow new minerals. Rare crystals had formed in the cracks and pores, binding the material more tightly together. In other words, the concrete had become stronger with age, the opposite of what happens to most modern concrete in seawater, which is gradually eaten away as salt attacks the steel bars inside it.
DA second discovery concerns small white lumps of lime that are often found in Roman concrete. These were long thought to be a sign of careless mixing. The materials scientist Dr Sara Okafor has argued instead that they resulted from a deliberate technique, in which quicklime was mixed directly with the ash and water, producing intense heat. When cracks later formed and water seeped in, the lumps dissolved and the calcium they contained recrystallised, sealing the cracks. Okafor’s team made samples using this method, cracked them deliberately and found that the cracks had closed within two weeks.
EThese findings are impressive, and they deserve the attention they have received. But they are often presented as proof that Roman concrete is simply better than modern concrete, and in my view this is wrong. The materials engineer Professor Mark Hensley points out that Roman concrete is far weaker under compression than modern concrete, and that it sets very slowly, sometimes taking months to reach full strength. It also contained no steel reinforcement, which is why Roman builders relied on arches and domes that keep the material in compression. A Roman mixture could not be used to build a skyscraper or a long, flat bridge.
FHensley also notes that we see only the Roman structures that survived. Countless others collapsed or were demolished long ago, and nobody writes newspaper articles about them. The surviving harbours and domes are, in a sense, a selection of the best, and it would be a mistake to judge the whole of Roman building by them. I find this point important, though it does not undo the scientific findings, which are based on the chemistry of the material rather than on its survival alone.
GWhat, then, can modern engineers learn? Not, I think, to copy the Roman recipe, but to rethink their priorities. Ordinary cement is made by heating limestone to very high temperatures, and its production accounts for around eight per cent of the world’s carbon dioxide emissions. Concrete that lasts for centuries rather than decades would need replacing far less often, and volcanic ash and similar materials can reduce the amount of cement required. The real lesson of Roman concrete is not that the ancients were cleverer than we are, but that durability is worth designing for.
Questions 14–17
Do the following statements agree with the claims of the writer in the reading passage? Choose YES if the statement agrees with the claims of the writer, NO if the statement contradicts the claims of the writer, or NOT GIVEN if it is impossible to say what the writer thinks about this.
- 14Popular accounts of Roman concrete exaggerate what the Romans knew.
- 15Roman concrete is superior to modern concrete in every respect.
- 16Hensley’s point about surviving structures shows that the chemical research is unreliable.
- 17Modern builders will soon begin using Okafor’s technique on a large scale.
Answers and explanations
Open one at a time to check as you go, or the key to mark them all.
Answer key: Questions 14–17Show
- 14Yes
- 15No
- 16No
- 17Not Given
14Popular accounts of Roman concrete exaggerate what the Romans knew.Answer
Answer: Yes
Paragraph A: newspapers claim a forgotten secret, but “the truth is both more interesting and more modest than that”.
15Roman concrete is superior to modern concrete in every respect.Answer
Answer: No
Paragraph E: the claim that Roman concrete is “simply better than modern concrete” is “in my view … wrong”.
16Hensley’s point about surviving structures shows that the chemical research is unreliable.Answer
Answer: No
Paragraph F: the writer finds the point important, “though it does not undo the scientific findings”.
17Modern builders will soon begin using Okafor’s technique on a large scale.Answer
Answer: Not Given
Paragraph D describes Okafor’s experiments and paragraph G discusses lessons in general, but the writer makes no prediction about her technique being adopted.
The rest of this passage
Other question types on the same text, like the paper.
More Yes / No / Not Given practice
Common questions
Are these real IELTS Reading questions?
No. They're original practice questions written in the official IELTS format and numbering, with answers and explanations. Real test questions aren't published.
How should I use the answers?
Answer every question first, then check. For each one you got wrong, read the explanation and find the line in the passage that gives the answer: that's where the trap or paraphrase is.
What's the difference between False and Not Given?
False (or No) means the passage says the opposite of the statement. Not Given means the passage doesn't say either way, even if the statement sounds likely.
Answer it in the app
See right and wrong at once with the reason for each. Free to start, nothing to install.