IELTS Reading · Reading Passage 2
The honest placebo: yes, no, not given
Yes / No / Not Given practice, questions 14–18, with the full passage and every answer explained. Try the questions first; the answers are folded away below.
- Questions
- 14–18
- Passage
- 688 words
- Level
- Medium
- Part
- 1 of 3 on this passage
The Honest Placebo
AFor as long as there has been medicine, doctors have known that patients sometimes recover after receiving treatments that could not possibly have worked. Physicians in the eighteenth century handed out pills of bread or coloured water to patients who demanded something, and noted with some embarrassment how often they seemed to help. The word itself betrays the attitude: “placebo” is Latin for “I shall please”, and for centuries it described a harmless deception practised on the anxious.
BModern research has turned the placebo from an embarrassment into a subject of study, and its effects turn out to be real but limited. Pain, nausea and depression respond to it; tumours and broken bones do not. The pharmacologist Dr Fiona Grant, in a review of 120 trials of pain treatments, found that around 30 per cent of patients given a dummy pill reported meaningful relief. The ritual of treatment matters a great deal. Two pills work better than one, larger pills better than small ones, and injections better than either. The psychologist Dr Kenji Morita gave volunteers identical pills for a mild electric shock, telling half that the pill cost several pounds and half that it had been heavily discounted; those who believed they had the expensive version reported significantly less pain.
CAll of this raises an obvious ethical problem. If a placebo works only because the patient believes it is real medicine, then prescribing one means deceiving the patient, and I do not believe that a doctor is ever entitled to do that, however kind the motive. There is also a hidden placebo problem in ordinary practice. A doctor who prescribes antibiotics for a cold, which is caused by a virus that antibiotics cannot touch, is offering a placebo of a particularly harmful kind, because every unnecessary prescription helps bacteria to develop resistance.
DA way round the ethical difficulty may have been found. In a trial run by Dr Elena Rossi, patients with irritable bowel syndrome were given pills that were clearly labelled as containing no active ingredient, and were told so plainly by the doctor. Remarkably, they reported greater improvement in their symptoms than a comparison group who received no pills at all. Similar results have since been reported for back pain and fatigue. These open-label placebos, as they are called, seem to work through expectation and the ritual of taking a pill, even when the patient knows the truth.
ENot everyone is convinced that the placebo effect is as powerful as such studies imply. The statistician Dr Martin Shaw argues that much of it is an illusion created by a phenomenon called regression to the mean. People tend to seek treatment, or enrol in trials, when their symptoms are at their worst, and symptoms that fluctuate will often improve on their own. Patients may also report feeling better simply to please the doctor who is treating them. Shaw’s point is an important corrective, and I think it explains a large part of what is usually called the placebo effect, though not all of it: in several trials, patients given a placebo improved more than those given nothing, which regression alone cannot explain.
FWhat, then, should doctors do with this knowledge? Not, in my view, prescribe sugar pills on a large scale. The more useful lesson is that the elements that make a placebo work, such as time, attention, warmth and a confident explanation, are part of good care in their own right. A consultation is not just a means of reaching a diagnosis; it is itself a kind of treatment. Health services that cut appointment times to a few minutes in order to save money may therefore be making a false economy, since patients who feel unheard are more likely to return.
GThe placebo effect shows that the mind can influence how we experience illness, but it is not magic, and it has clear limits. A dummy pill can make pain easier to bear; it cannot shrink a tumour or mend a fracture. I would be deeply wary of anyone who claims that belief alone can cure serious disease.
Questions 14–18
Do the following statements agree with the claims of the writer in the reading passage? Choose YES if the statement agrees with the claims of the writer, NO if the statement contradicts the claims of the writer, or NOT GIVEN if it is impossible to say what the writer thinks about this.
- 14It is never acceptable for doctors to mislead patients about a treatment.
- 15Prescribing antibiotics for a cold does no harm, even if it does no good.
- 16Open-label placebos are likely to become a standard treatment in hospitals.
- 17Regression to the mean explains the whole of the placebo effect.
- 18Shortening consultations to save money may prove more costly in the end.
Answers and explanations
Open one at a time to check as you go, or the key to mark them all.
Answer key: Questions 14–18Show
- 14Yes
- 15No
- 16Not Given
- 17No
- 18Yes
14It is never acceptable for doctors to mislead patients about a treatment.Answer
Answer: Yes
Paragraph C: “I do not believe that a doctor is ever entitled to do that, however kind the motive.”
15Prescribing antibiotics for a cold does no harm, even if it does no good.Answer
Answer: No
Paragraph C: it is “a placebo of a particularly harmful kind, because every unnecessary prescription helps bacteria to develop resistance”.
16Open-label placebos are likely to become a standard treatment in hospitals.Answer
Answer: Not Given
Paragraph D describes trials of open-label placebos, but the writer makes no prediction about their future use.
17Regression to the mean explains the whole of the placebo effect.Answer
Answer: No
Paragraph E: the writer thinks it explains “a large part … though not all of it”.
18Shortening consultations to save money may prove more costly in the end.Answer
Answer: Yes
Paragraph F: health services that cut appointment times “may therefore be making a false economy, since patients who feel unheard are more likely to return”.
The rest of this passage
Other question types on the same text, like the paper.
More Yes / No / Not Given practice
Common questions
Are these real IELTS Reading questions?
No. They're original practice questions written in the official IELTS format and numbering, with answers and explanations. Real test questions aren't published.
How should I use the answers?
Answer every question first, then check. For each one you got wrong, read the explanation and find the line in the passage that gives the answer: that's where the trap or paraphrase is.
What's the difference between False and Not Given?
False (or No) means the passage says the opposite of the statement. Not Given means the passage doesn't say either way, even if the statement sounds likely.
Answer it in the app
See right and wrong at once with the reason for each. Free to start, nothing to install.